Hatchet Job 2014 | Previous years | Manifesto | Press

Smaller hatchet

PRESS

For all enquiries, including sponsorship, please get in touch at hatchetjob@theomnivore.com

Here’s some of the media coverage the prize has received over the years:

2013-14

GUARDIAN

Hatchet Job of the Year award draws and quarters shortlist
Hatchet Job of the Year shortlist – 2013′s most negative reviews in quotes 
Hatchet Job of the Year goes to Gill for Morrissey broadside
Alex Clark: The Hatchet Job of the Year doesn’t cut it

INDEPENDENT

Hatchet Job of the Year 2014: And this year’s prize for the best literary hatchet job goes to… 

TELEGRAPH

‘No rhythm, no beauty, no humour’ Hatchet Job of the Year shortlist announced
Hatchet Job of the Year 2014: AA Gill wins for his review of Morrissey’s autobiography
Sameer Rahim: Hatchet Job of the Year 2014: Let’s salute the bravery of critics

DAILY MAIL

Craig Brown: Hooray! I’m officially a Hatchet Man
Morrissey mauling wins Hatchet Job review prize

EVENING STANDARD

Literary critics vie for award: potted shrimp 
Mark Haddon has a humour failure 
Brian Sewell: How to wield the hatchet is a fine art in itself
Londoner’s Diary: Old dogs seize the moment
Londoner’s Diary: We hope AA likes the taste of shrimp
AA Gill’s mockery of singer Morrissey’s autobiography wins Hatchet Job of the Year prize
Five things David Sexton ate this week

NME

Review of Morrissey’s autobiography named Hatchet Job of the Year

BBC

Morrissey critique wins Hatchet Job award
Open Book with Mariella Frostrup (19 minutes in)

ASSOCIATED PRESS

Eleanor Catton and Douglas Coupland up for Hatchet Job Award

LA TIMES

Hatchet Job of the Year announces 2013 shortlist, dings Morrissey 

NEW YORK TIMES

AA Gill honoured for top hatchet job

FLAVORWIRE

AA Gill Wins Hatchet Job of The Year Award

SLATE

Hatchet Job of the Year is the worst award of its generation

THE WEEK

AA Gill rewarded for Morrissey hatchet job

MONOCLE RADIO

Midori House 578

ANDREW SULLIVAN’S DAILY DISH

In Praise of the Hatchet Job

CBC RADIO Canada

Do nasty book reviews have cultural value

2012-13

UK Television
BBC1 Have I got News For You (Episode 4, Series 45)
BBC2 Culture Show: Episode 27 (25 minutes in)

UK Radio
BBC Radio 4: Today programme (13/02/13)
BBC World Service (08/01/13)
BBC Radio Ulster Arts Extra (10/01/13, 9 minutes in)

US Radio
NPR: Critic Snags Award For Reviews Sizzling With Anger (13/01/13)

*

BBC NEWS
Long wins Hatchet Job award for scathing Cusk review (13/02/13)

GUARDIAN
Hatchet Job of the Year shortlist lines up sharpest reviews (including interactive gallery)(08/01/13)
Jonathan Jones: Art criticism has become too fawning – time for a best hatchet job award?(09/01/13)
The week in books (11/01/13)
Hatchet Job of the Year goes to assault on Rachel Cusk (12/02/13)
Today’s media stories from the papers (13/02/13)

HUFFINGTON POST
Hatchet Job Prize Winner For 2012 Announced (AP) (12/02/13)

INDEPENDENT
Book critics with acid pens vie for Hatchet Job of the Year award (09/01/13)
John Walsh: Hatchet jobs: Agony for the author but bliss for us to read (13/02/13)
AC Grayling: Don’t tell lies. But don’t tell untimely truths either (17/02/13)

LITERARY REVIEW
Dominic Sandbrook: Bury the Hatchet (01/05/13)

LONDON EVENING STANDARD
Londoner’s Diary: A night for sharp scribes: Hatchet Job of the Year Awards (07/12/12)
Londoner’s Diary: Suck up and you’re a winner (24/01/13)
Londoner’s Diary: Who would be a media hound? (12/02/13)
Londoner’s Diary: Poor Rachel Cusk gets a mauling for her mewling (13/02/13)

LOS ANGELES TIMES
And the Golden Hatchet goes to … (08/01/13)

NEW STATESMAN
A historian’s hatchet job (12/02/13)
Interview with Leon Wieseltier (30/05/13)

NEW YORK TIMES
Clive James: Whither the Hatchet Job? (12/02/13)

PARIS REVIEW
The Hatchet Falls (09/01/13)

SALON
And the year’s most scathing book reviews are … (09/01/13)
Shrewd takedown of Rachel Cusk’s Aftermath wins Hatchet Job of the Year Award (13/02/13)

SCOTSMAN
Scotsman critic nominated for most scathing book review of the year (09/01/13)

SPECTATOR
Interview with James Wood (12/04/13)

TELEGRAPH
Hatchet jobs on Rushdie and Amis up for award (09/01/13)
Allan Massie: Everyone enjoys a really savage review (11/01/13)
Damian Thompson: Savaged by a gentleman critic (18/01/13)
Top 10 vicious literary hatchet jobs (12/02/13)

TIME
Ouch! Check Out the Harshest Book Review of the Year (13/02/13)

WASHINGTON POST
Ron Charles: Hatchet Job of the Year Award (12/02/13)

THE WEEK
Authors wince at pick of year’s most insulting book reviews (09/01/13)

2011-12

BBC NEWS
Scathing reviews jostle for Hatchet Prize (11/01/12)

GUARDIAN
Book critics to get their own prize for reviews (10/01/12)
John Sutherland: Which book reviewer will win the ‘hatchet job of the year’ award?(12/01/12)
Should we celebrate scathing book reviews? | The conversation (3/02/12)
Review of The Hours author’s latest book wins inaugural hatchet job award (07/02/12)
Sam Leith: The Week in Books (11/02/12)

HUFFINGTON POST
Harshest Ever Book Reviews: Writers the Critics Savaged (11/01/12)
Best Rip Job of the Year (05/02/12)
Adam Mars-Jones Wins Hatchet Job Of The Year Award For Writing Meanest Book Review(07/02/12)

INDEPENDENT
Wars of words: when critics throw the book at authors (11/11/12)
John Walsh: A hatchet job is not the real thing unless it’s done with wit and learning(12/01/12)
Boyd Tonkin: Put the hatchet in the other hand (13/01/12)
The Diary (06/01/12)

INDEPENDENT ON SUNDAY
Between The Covers (15/01/12)
Between The Covers (12/02/12)
The Diary (27/11/12)
DJ Taylor: All Hail Patten (05/02/12)
The Blaggers Guide to … The Hatchet Job of the Year (29/01/12)

LONDON EVENING STANDARD
Londoner’s Diary: Words never hurt, then (08/12/11)
Londoner’s Diary (10/01/12)
David Sexton: In praise of a literary tradition: the hatchet job (12/01/12)
Londoner’s Diary: West goes missing on his hatchet job (08/02/12)
Londoner’s Diary: Bigger Fish Sought for Hatchet Job Prize (20/08/12)
Londoner’s Diary: Booker Prize Books (11/09/12)

LOS ANGELES TIMES
Introducing the Hatchet Job of the Year Award (Jacket Copy Blog) (11/01/12)

NEW STATESMAN
Axes to Grind (Cultural Capital Blog) (07/01/12)
Burying the Hatchet (Cultural Capital Blog) (08/02/12)

NEW YORK TIMES
A New Honour for the Hatchet Job (Arts Beat Blog) (30/01/12)

NOUVEL OBSERVATEUR
Téléphone rouge: Un prix à Londres… (30/01/12)

OBSERVER
Robert McCrum on books (15/01/12)
Adam Mars-Jones: The only bad review is one whose writing is soggy (10/02/12)
Victoria Coren: We lose free speech at our peril (12/02/12)

SPECTATOR
Hatchet Job of the Year (Spectator Book Blog) (07/01/12)

TELEGRAPH
‘The author could not write bum on a wall’ – high praise for a good hatchet job (12/01/12)
Book review hatchet jobs: a crusade against dullness? (10/01/12)
Allan Massie: ‘One by one, Lord Macaulay’s predictions are coming true’ (16/01/12)

THE TIMES
Erica Wagner: The Hatchet Job of the Year (14/01/12)

TLS
Mary Beard, A Don’s Life: Hatchet Job of the Year (13/01/12)
NB by JC (10/02/12)
Mary Beard, A Don’s Life: Hatchet Job Announced (08/02/12)
Peter Stothard, TLS Blog: O the Competition! (09/02/12)

WALL STREET JOURNAL
Best Hatchet Jobs (Ideas Market Blog) (11/01/12)

WASHINGTON POST
Britain’s Hatchet Job Honours the Art of the Lacerating Book Review (08/01/11)

*

UK RADIO
BBC Radio 4: Today programme
BBC Radio Ulster Arts Extra 
BBC Scotland: MacAuley & Co (51 minutes in) 

US RADIO
National Public Radio: Morning Edition
Southern Californian Radio KPCC 89.3: Madeleine Brand Show
Monocle Radio

Share Button